PlatformIO + ARM mbed

This was a total failure.

There are two routes to installing ARM mbed. One is to install the mbed Studio software. Unfortunately, for Linux, this supports only a couple of older Ubuntu versions (16.04 or 18.04), so it's not an option (I use Arch Linux). Why an IDE is so specific about OS versions I couldn't say, but it's not a good sign.

The second option is to use PlatformIO, and select mbed as the platform.

This superficially worked, and downloaded about 2 Gb of stuff, and a blinky program (taken from the mbed website) compiled (after a very long process of compiling every single source file in the mbed distribution) and claimed to download to the nRF52840 development board. But it didn't run. And debugging didn't reveal anything obvious, apart from the fact that the code seemed to hang in a line that said "led1 = !led1;", with led1 being a C++ object referring to one of the LEDs on the nRF52840 development board.

And there we come to one of the problems of these highly integrated systems. If I'd been using GCC + OpenOCD + GDB and something didn't work, I'd quickly be able to figure out what the problem was. Here, that's not so easy.

(Also, there's something up with the build dependencies for mbed under PlatformIO. Every single mbed source file gets rebuilt whenever you do anything. It's not usable. A 10-line blinky program should compile in a few seconds, not take multiple minutes to build.)

So, blinky don't blink. That's pretty fatal.

I could try to work out what's going on, but life is too short. Nordic aren't involved in mbed development any more as far as I can tell, so I don't think it's really a viable option for development on their devices. (I could be wrong here, since I've not spent time to investigate in detail.)

I'm not going to go any further with mbed.